I chose Plymouth because they had a good relationship with the natives and Jamestown did not. It began with women,men and children not just men like Jamestown. Jamestown had rough first few years while Plymouth had a rough first winter. Plymouth grew in size and became the largest colony. Plymouth lasted longer than Jamestown. Plymouth had the Mayflower Compact and Jamestown had Representative Government. Plymouth came for freedom to worship and business venture. The pilgrims started thanksgiving. They survived due to Squanto,Chief Massasoit and Samoset. William Bradford was the leader.